Cover for Dr. Jay Carter Johnston's Obituary
Dr. Jay Carter Johnston Profile Photo

Dr. Jay Carter Johnston

d. Nov 12, 2026

Oklahoma City

Dr. Jay Carter Johnston

Dr. Jay Carter Johnston, a lifelong Oklahoma City resident, beloved husband, father, grandfather, physician, and friend, passed away peacefully at his home from a rare neurological disorder at the age of 85, with Susan, his loving wife of 60 years, by his side.

Jay was born in Oklahoma City on July 22, 1941, to Ralph Johnston and Valma (Ulrich) Johnston at St. Anthony Hospital. Jay was fiercely proud of his Oklahoma heritage. His grandfather was an Oklahoma lawman, and his grandmother was Cherokee. He grew up in a small rock house his father built, across from what is now Deaconess Hospital. Those roots run deep, and he carried a lifelong appreciation for the people, places, and traditions that shaped him.

Jay's devotion to the Oklahoma Sooners began early. As a Boy Scout, he rode a bus to Norman to usher at OU football games, earning free admission, a hot dog, and a drink in return. It was the beginning of a lifelong love of Sooner football.

Jay was a proud 1959 graduate of Putnam City High School, where he was an All-District guard on the football team. He maintained lifelong friendships with his Putnam City classmates, gathering annually with his cherished "Club of 12," a group of friends whose bond stretched all the way back to their elementary school years.

Jay's path to medicine began with a fifth-grade teacher who recognized his gift for science. That simple encouragement stayed with him and helped shape the course of his life. At Central State College, now the University of Central Oklahoma, he completed his medical school prerequisites in just three years. To pay his way through college, he sold shoes at Crum's in downtown Oklahoma City and worked at the TG&Y loading dock. He was also a member of the Army National Guard. He graduated from the University of Oklahoma College of Medicine in 1966, then completed a two-year residency in internal medicine followed by three years of ophthalmology training.

While in medical school, Jay was introduced on a blind date to a nursing student from Lawton named Susan Banta. What began as a blind date became the love story of a lifetime. They married about a year later, raised three children, and celebrated their 60th wedding anniversary this past June.

Jay converted to Catholicism and had been an active member of Christ the King Catholic Church since the 1970s, where he served as a Eucharistic minister. His faith was central to his life, and he lived it through compassion, generosity, and service to others. Outside of work and church, he and Susan were active members of Quail Creek Golf and Country Club, where they enjoyed tennis, and as they got older, golf. They were blessed with many lifelong friends and an active social life. Jay and Susan also treasured their annual family trips to their condo in Crested Butte, Colorado, a cherished tradition that began when their children were young and continued for decades.

For 52 years, until he retired in 2023, Jay cared for people throughout Oklahoma. An exceptionally gifted ophthalmologist and surgeon, he was also a brilliant physician with an extraordinary instinct for medicine, and more than once he spotted signs of a serious medical problem, sometimes saving lives. He often said the "art of medicine" had as much to do with compassion and connection as science, and he believed in treating the person, not just the condition. Patients traveled from across Oklahoma to be under his care, and he formed lasting friendships with patients, farmers, ranchers, and families throughout the state. He had an easy warmth, a genuine curiosity about others, and a wonderful sense of humor. Jay loved to laugh and make others laugh, and his quick wit and playful spirit made him unforgettable.

Jay was a lifelong member of the American Academy of Ophthalmology and the American Medical Association. He was also honored with the Bertha Levy Health Care Award for his volunteer service to Variety Care.

For all his professional accomplishments and the countless lives he touched, Jay's greatest love and proudest achievement was his family. Susan, his children, and his grandchildren were the bright spots in his life. Nothing made him happier than having them all together, whether celebrating milestones or enjoying family vacations. Those trips became treasured traditions filled with laughter and stories.

Jay is survived by his beloved wife of 60 years, Susan; his three children and their families: Carter Johnston and his children, Gavin and Phoebe; Chris Johnston and his sons, Drake and Ross; and Leslie, her husband, Josh Payne, and her daughter, Audrey Buford; and many extended family members. He was preceded in death by his brother, Robert Val Johnston of Tulsa, Oklahoma.

Jay lived a remarkable 85 years. He was a gifted physician, devoted husband, loving father and grandfather, loyal friend, proud Oklahoman, and a man who never lost his sense of humor.

He leaves behind generations of people whose lives were made better by knowing him: patients he helped, friends who will never forget his laughter, and a family who will forever cherish his love. We are heartbroken that he is gone, but immeasurably grateful that we got to love him and be loved by him.

Upcoming Services

Viewing

Thursday, November 19, 2026

9:00 am - 3:00 pm (Central time)

Smith & Kernke Funeral Homes & Crematory - May Ave

14624 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73134

Get Directions

Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text. Standard text messaging rates apply.

Prayer Service

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Starts at 5:00 pm (Central time)

Smith & Kernke Funeral Homes & Crematory - May Ave

14624 N May Ave, Oklahoma City, OK 73134

Get Directions

Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text. Standard text messaging rates apply.

Mass

Friday, November 20, 2026

Starts at 10:30 am (Central time)

Christ the King Catholic Church

8005 Dorset Drive, Oklahoma City, OK 73116

Get Directions

Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text. Standard text messaging rates apply.

Interment

Friday, November 20, 2026

Get Directions

Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text. Standard text messaging rates apply.

Guestbook

Visits: 182

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the
Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors